Comparison
Edith vs Setapp
A subscription to hundreds of apps from many developers, or one native app you buy once, with the same command line and agent access across every tool.
Updated by Pulkit
The short answer
Pick Setapp if you want many kinds of software from one subscription: hundreds of apps from different developers, on your Mac and, on some plans, your iPhone and iPad. It covers far more categories than Edith does.
Pick Edith if most of what you want from a bundle is Mac utilities and developer tools, and you would rather pay once. It is $35 once for one Mac, with every extension in one native app, one settings window, one command line and one MCP server for your coding agents.
Keep Setapp if you rely on a dedicated app it includes, such as iStat Menus for sensor readings or CleanShot X for annotated screenshots. Edith's versions of those jobs are narrower.
Two different kinds of bundle
Setapp is a catalog. Its home page describes 300+ Mac, iOS and web apps in one subscription, each made and updated by its own developer, each installed and configured on its own.
Edith is one app built from extensions that share a design, settings, a menu bar, a notch, a command line called ed and an MCP server. You install only the extensions you want, and they start when you use them.
Where they overlap
Several Setapp apps do jobs an Edith extension also does. Paste and Edith's Clipboard keep a searchable clipboard history. CleanMyMac and Edith's Cleaner free disk space, although Edith's Cleaner targets developer caches and build output. iStat Menus and Menu Bar Stats put system load in the menu bar. Lungo and Keep Awake stop your Mac from sleeping. CleanShot X and Screen Recorder record your screen.
Edith also covers jobs aimed at developers: Usage for coding-agent cost and limits, Agents for every agent on one board, Machines for SSH servers and Homebrew for packages without the terminal.
Price over a year or two
Setapp's Mac plan is $14.99 a month for one Mac, with a 7-day free trial, and yearly billing saves up to 40%. Edith is $35 once for one Mac and $7 for each extra Mac, with no renewal. Setapp's price buys access to far more software; Edith's buys fewer tools that you keep.
Price
Prices checked on from Setapp's own site or App Store listing. Edith's price is the one on the pricing page.
| App | How it is sold | Price | Runs on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edith | One-time purchase | $35 once for one Mac, plus $7 for each additional Mac. Every extension and the updates that follow are included. 30-day refund. | macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon |
| Setapp | Subscription | Mac plan $14.99 a month for one Mac. Mac + iOS $18.99 a month. Power User $22.99 a month for four Macs and four iOS devices. 7-day free trial, and yearly billing saves up to 40%. | Mac, iOS and web apps |
Feature by feature
Each Setapp feature links to the page it is described on. Full means Edith does the same job, partial means it does part of it, and no means it does not.
| Setapp feature | Setapp | Edith | How Edith covers it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hundreds of apps from many developers | Full | No | Edith is one app with its own extensions, not a catalog of separate apps. |
| Clipboard manager (Paste) | Full | Full | ClipboardSearchable history of text, links, images and files, with pins. No iPhone sync. |
| Mac cleanup (CleanMyMac) | Full | Partial | CleanerEdith's Cleaner finds developer caches, build output and unused git worktrees, and moves them to the Trash. |
| System monitor in the menu bar (iStat Menus) | Full | Partial | Menu Bar StatsCPU and memory percentages only, with a small panel on click. |
| Keep your Mac awake (Lungo) | Full | Full | Keep AwakeTurn Keep Awake on from Home, the notch or settings, and the Mac and display stay awake until you switch it off. |
| Screenshots and screen recording (CleanShot X) | Full | Partial | Screen RecorderScreen Recorder records a display or windows, or a time-lapse. No screenshot annotation. |
| iPhone and iPad apps | Full | No | There is no Edith for iPhone or iPad. |
| AI credits included | Full | No | Edith includes no AI credits. Your own coding agents can call it over MCP. |
When to keep Setapp
- Far more kinds of software than Edith covers, across Mac, iOS and web apps.
- Dedicated apps that go deeper on one job, such as iStat Menus for temperatures, fans and other sensors, or CleanShot X for annotated screenshots.
- iPhone and iPad apps on the Mac + iOS and Power User plans.
- AI credits included with every plan.
- A 7-day free trial before you pay.
What Edith does not do
- No iOS apps and no software outside Edith's own extensions.
- Menu Bar Stats shows CPU and memory only, with no temperature, fan or other sensor readings.
- Screen Recorder records video and time-lapses but has no screenshot annotation.
- Cleaner is built for developer caches, not general system junk or malware.
- No free trial. There is a refund window instead, and the price is $35 up front.
- Edith checks its license online and asks to reconnect after 3 days offline.
Switching from Setapp
- 1
List the Setapp apps you open each week
Check which of them map to an Edith extension in the table above, and which have no Edith equivalent.
- 2
Install Edith and the matching extensions
Open Extensions in Edith and install the ones that replace your Setapp apps, such as Clipboard, Cleaner, Menu Bar Stats or Keep Awake. Each one has its own page and settings.
- 3
Keep the apps Edith does not replace
If you depend on an app with no Edith equivalent, buy it directly from its developer or keep Setapp for it.
- 4
Script or delegate the rest
Every Edith command runs from the terminal with
edand returns JSON, and the MCP server lets Claude Code, Codex, Cursor or VS Code use the same commands. - 5
Decide within the refund window
Use Edith and Setapp side by side for a while. If Edith turns out not to replace Setapp for you, email within 30 days of buying for a full refund.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Setapp cost?
Setapp's Mac plan is $14.99 a month for one Mac. Mac + iOS is $18.99 a month, and Power User is $22.99 a month for four Macs and four iOS devices. Every plan starts with a 7-day free trial, and yearly billing saves up to 40%.
Does Setapp have more apps than Edith has extensions?
Yes, by a wide margin. Setapp's catalog has hundreds of apps across many categories. Edith focuses on Mac utilities, desk tools, media tools and developer tools.
What do I keep if I stop paying?
Edith is a one-time purchase: you keep using it, with the updates that follow. Setapp is a subscription, so check Setapp's own terms for what happens to its apps when a plan ends.
Can I use Edith and Setapp together?
Yes. You can keep the Setapp apps Edith does not replace and let Edith handle the utilities it covers.
Sources
Every Setapp fact on this page comes from these pages, checked on . Edith is made by the author of this page. Read how we compare for the method and how often facts are rechecked.
- Setapp pricing
- Setapp home page
- Paste on Setapp
- CleanMyMac on Setapp
- iStat Menus on Setapp
- Lungo on Setapp
- CleanShot X on Setapp
Updated
More comparisons
- Edith vs CleanMyMac: Mac Cleanup Tools ComparedEdith vs CleanMyMac on Mac: malware checks and one-click cleanup on a subscription or license, or developer cache cleanup and updates in one app.
- Edith vs Raycast: One-Time Mac Toolkit ComparedEdith vs Raycast on Mac: a free launcher with paid AI plans, or one payment for a launcher plus agent usage, MCP control and Mac utilities.
Get Edith.
From $35 once. No subscription. No account.
Needs a license key · macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon · 6.4 MB