Skip to content
Edith

Comparison

Edith vs CleanMyMac

A dedicated Mac cleaner with malware protection, or a set of extensions that clean developer caches, map your disk, update apps and show what is running.

Updated by

The short answer

Pick CleanMyMac if you want one app that cleans general system clutter, checks for malware, runs a one-click care routine, finds duplicate files and tidies cloud storage. Edith has no malware scanning and no one-click routine.

Pick Edith if your disk fills up with Xcode data, package caches, node_modules and old git worktrees, and you also want app updates, an uninstaller, a disk map and menu bar stats in the same app, all for $35 once for one Mac.

Keep CleanMyMac if threat protection or cloud storage cleanup matters to you. Those jobs are outside what Edith does.

How the cleaning differs

CleanMyMac's product page groups its features into Smart Care, a routine that cleans, scans for threats, speeds things up, runs updates and declutters storage, plus separate sections for freeing space, threat protection, performance, uninstalling and updating apps, clutter and cloud storage.

Edith's Cleaner is narrower and aimed at developers. It finds caches from Xcode, simulators, Swift packages, CocoaPods, npm, pnpm, Yarn, Bun, pip, uv, Cargo, Go, Gradle, Homebrew and editors such as VS Code, Cursor and JetBrains IDEs, plus build output like node_modules and Cargo target folders, and unused git worktrees. You review every item, and everything you clean goes to the Trash so you can put it back.

The rest of the overlap

App Updates checks your apps and Homebrew for newer versions, shows release notes and the exact command, and uninstalls apps along with the files they leave behind. Disk Map draws any folder as blocks sized by space used, so large files stand out. Running Apps lists open apps by CPU and memory and quits the ones you pick, and Menu Bar Stats keeps CPU and memory percentages in the menu bar.

Cleaner and App Updates also run from the terminal, with commands such as ed cleaner scan and ed maintenance updates, and coding agents can call them over MCP. Commands that delete something return a preview until they are confirmed.

How each is sold

CleanMyMac is free to download with a 7-day trial. On the US Mac App Store it is $39.99 a year or $9.99 a month, and Plus is $65.99 a year. MacPaw also offers a one-time purchase, which covers updates to the current major version only; later major versions are a paid upgrade. Prices vary by region. Edith is $35 once for one Mac, with later updates included.

Price

Prices checked on from CleanMyMac's own site or App Store listing. Edith's price is the one on the pricing page.

AppHow it is soldPriceRuns on
EdithOne-time purchase$35 once for one Mac, plus $7 for each additional Mac. Every extension and the updates that follow are included. 30-day refund.macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon
CleanMyMacSubscription or one-time licenseFree download with a 7-day trial. On the US Mac App Store: $39.99 a year, $9.99 a month, or Plus at $65.99 a year. MacPaw also offers a one-time purchase that covers the current major version. Prices vary by region.macOS 11 or later

Feature by feature

Each CleanMyMac feature links to the page it is described on. Full means Edith does the same job, partial means it does part of it, and no means it does not.

CleanMyMac featureCleanMyMacEdithHow Edith covers it
Free up space from junk and cachesFullPartial
CleanerEdith cleans developer caches, build output and git worktrees, not general system junk.
Threat protectionFullNo
Edith has no malware scanning or removal.
Smart Care one-click routineFullNo
Each Edith extension runs its own scan. There is no combined routine.
Performance toolsFullPartial
Running AppsRunning Apps shows CPU and memory per app and quits what you choose. No speed-up routines.
Uninstall apps without leftoversFullFull
App UpdatesUntick any file you want to keep, and the rest goes to the Trash.
Update appsFullFull
App UpdatesCovers your apps and Homebrew, with release notes before you update.
Find clutter and large filesFullPartial
Disk MapDisk Map shows the largest folders and files as a map. It does not look for duplicates.
Cloud storage cleanupFullNo
Edith only looks at folders and drives on your Mac.

When to keep CleanMyMac

  • Threat protection that scans for and removes malware.
  • Smart Care, a single routine that cleans, scans, updates and declutters together.
  • General system junk cleanup, beyond developer caches.
  • Cloud storage cleanup.
  • Runs on macOS 11 or later, and is sold on the Mac App Store as well as by MacPaw directly.

What Edith does not do

  • No malware scanning or removal.
  • No one-click routine across cleanup, updates and performance.
  • Cleaner targets developer caches and build output, not mail, language files or other system junk.
  • It does not clean up cloud storage or find duplicate files.
  • Edith needs macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon, where CleanMyMac runs on macOS 11 or later.
  • Edith checks its license online and asks to reconnect after 3 days offline.

Switching from CleanMyMac

  1. 1

    Run Edith's Cleaner first

    Install Cleaner and scan. A scan only reads folders, so you can compare what it finds with CleanMyMac's results before you remove anything.

  2. 2

    Move app updates and uninstalls over

    Install App Updates. It checks your apps and Homebrew for newer versions and removes apps with their leftover files.

  3. 3

    Use Disk Map for the big stuff

    Point Disk Map at your home folder or a drive to find what takes the most space, then move what you choose to the Trash.

  4. 4

    Decide what to do about malware checks

    Edith does not replace threat protection. If you want that, keep CleanMyMac or another security tool.

  5. 5

    Decide within the refund window

    Use Edith and CleanMyMac side by side for a while. If Edith turns out not to replace CleanMyMac for you, email within 30 days of buying for a full refund.

Frequently asked questions

Is CleanMyMac a subscription?

It is sold both ways. The Mac App Store offers yearly and monthly plans, and MacPaw also offers a one-time purchase that covers updates to the current major version. MacPaw says subscriptions include future major versions.

Does Edith remove malware?

No. Edith has no malware scanning or removal. Keep CleanMyMac or another security tool if you need it.

Is Edith's Cleaner safe to run?

A scan only reads folders. You review every item before cleaning, and everything you clean moves to the Trash, so you can restore it until you empty the Trash.

Who is Edith's Cleaner for?

Mostly developers. It knows where Xcode, package managers, build tools and editors keep caches, and it finds git worktrees you no longer use.

Sources

Every CleanMyMac fact on this page comes from these pages, checked on . Edith is made by the author of this page. Read how we compare for the method and how often facts are rechecked.

Updated

Get Edith.

From $35 once. No subscription. No account.

Download for macOS

Needs a license key · macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon · 6.4 MB